(All (Parentheses))

Share this post

Promised Lands

keithuhlich.substack.com

Discover more from (All (Parentheses))

Writings by Keith Uhlich, and others
Continue reading
Sign in
Time Out New York

Promised Lands

Time Out New York Project: Issue #749, February 4–February 10, 2010

Keith Uhlich
May 14, 2021
Share this post

Promised Lands

keithuhlich.substack.com
Share

★★☆☆☆

Dir. Susan Sontag. 1974. N/R. 87mins. In Hebrew, French and English. Documentary.

Strong and pointed as Susan Sontag’s intellect could be, she was sometimes undone by the trendiness of her topics. Case in point: Promised Lands, her unfocused documentary portrait of Israel during and immediately after the 1973 Yom Kippur War. Sontag and a skeleton crew photograph this war-torn nation with a fashionable inquisitiveness — as if it’s the mod place for the intelligentsia to bear witness to the ongoing Arab-Israeli conflict.

Interview-wise, there’s some one-on-one bloviating with a writer (Yoram Kaniuk) and a physicist (Yuval Ne’eman), but the film largely lumbers between locales — the Wailing Wall; a barren desert littered with war dead — in a vain search for cohesion and profundity. Sontag occasionally trips into brilliance: A midfilm montage of exhibits in a government-sanctioned wax museum (featuring everything from the Eichmann trial to Golda Meir’s powwow with JFK) is a lacerating critique of official histories. And there’s a sickening sequence in a psychiatric ward where doctors re-create battlefield conditions for a shell-shocked soldier, with the intent of healing him.

Yet these are isolated moments of insight amid drudgery. Sontag’s true talent was for the printed word; behind the camera, her limitations come more harshly to light. Upon Promised Land’s release, she recounted her experiences in Vogue — an all-too-appropriate forum since her film is mostly chic posturing.—Keith Uhlich



Links

  • Time Out

  • Letterboxd

  • PDF

  • The Completist: Archive: 2010

Share this post

Promised Lands

keithuhlich.substack.com
Share
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Keith Uhlich
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing